Keep the Deer from Eating the Plants in Your Garden
As a gardening enthusiast, I love seeing deer in the wild, until those graceful creatures turn my garden into their personal buffet. Calling deer a nuisance is putting it mildly: a hungry herd can strip a garden overnight. Over the years I’ve made it my mission to find humane, non-harmful ways to keep deer out of my garden, without needing to fence in our entire property.
There’s a whole arsenal of deer deterrent strategies out there, from physical barriers that block their path to smelly repellents that send them off to find dinner elsewhere. The options can feel overwhelming, so I’ve spent seasons testing to find what actually works, and just as important, what doesn’t.
Keep reading for the deer repellent methods, deer-resistant plants, and garden layout tricks that have made the most significant difference for me, plus a few popular “wives’ tale” remedies that sound great online but never deliver for me personally.
On my blog Living Large in A Small House, I may sometimes use affiliate links, which means a small commission is earned if you purchase via the link. The price will be the same whether you use the affiliate link or go directly to the vendor’s website using a non-affiliate link. You can find my full Disclosure Policy HERE
Every yard and every deer herd is different. What works like a charm for one gardener might only mildly inconvenience someone else’s antlered visitors. Experimenting with a mix of methods is essential. And no, you don’t need to fence in your whole property to keep deer from eating your plants. Through trial and error, I’ve found a handful of methods that consistently deliver results, fence or no fence.
Understanding Deer Behavior: Why Deer Eat Garden Plants
Before we dive into how to keep deer out of the garden, it helps to understand why they show up in the first place. Understanding deer behavior comes down to two things: their feeding habits and what in your yard is drawing them in.
Deer Habitats and Feeding Patterns
Deer, like the white-tailed deer common across most of the U.S., aren’t wandering aimlessly. They’re on a constant hunt for food, and they’re hungry often. Biologists estimate deer eat around 6 to 8 pounds of vegetation a day; anyone who’s watched a herd work through a garden bed knows it can feel like a lot more. Deer favor edge habitats, the spots where forest meets open space, because they offer the widest variety of food sources.
In our case, a resident family of deer lives in the wooded area along our cul-de-sac, which is surrounded by water. Each year brings new fawns that need to eat enough to grow strong before finding their own territory, and some seasons a buck sticks around well past the rut. It’s a good reminder that deer pressure in a garden isn’t a one-time problem. It’s a season-long, often year-round, relationship to manage.
These agile climbers and jumpers cover large home ranges searching for their next meal, guided by a strong sense of smell that leads them straight to the tastiest, most nutritious plants. I’m doing my best to make sure they avoid my garden. I’m the only one in the neighborhood who has been successfully able to enjoy my tulips in the spring.
What Attracts Deer to a Garden
Ornamentals and vegetable gardens alike can look like an all-you-can-eat buffet to a hungry deer. They’re drawn to herbaceous perennials, vegetables, and fruit trees most of all, though their preferences shift to what’s available, which is why rotating repellents matters.
Deer aren’t fans of every scent and taste, though. There are repellents on the market that have smells ranging from minty to rotten eggs. There are numerous recipes you can also find online to “DIY” your spray. I, personally, know that making my own would be one step to add to my routine that I don’t want to do.
Become a Friend of Living Large
Be the first to see affordable decorating ideas, gardening tips and tricks, along with great organizing, entertaining ideas and easy recipes
Deer Deterrent Strategies That Actually Work
Keeping deer out of the garden comes down to making your space as unappealing to them as possible. Here are the deer control methods that have consistently worked for me:
Repellent Sprays and Solutions
Deer are especially drawn to young plants and tender new buds, so deterrents need to start early, at the first sign of new growth each spring.
I begin the season by spraying the entire perimeter of the yard with Liquid Fence, timing the first application to when early bloomers like hellebores start flowering and the nibbling begins. A second application follows about a week later, then I use the Liquid Fence every four weeks. In between the Liquid Fence, I use Deer Out every four weeks. So my garden is getting an application every other week. If it rains, I head out and spray one or the other again. I continue my spray routine through the whole growing season.
As soon as my tulips start to emerge, I spray them with Platskydd Animal Repellent Spray. This spray I use as soon as I see young buds on any of my plants. I also use it regularly on the plants I know they love, like my impatiens in my front window boxes.
Scent-Based Deer Deterrents: And a Few Wives’ Tales to Skip
Deer have sensitive noses, and I lean on that heavily. I alternate between rancid egg smell, minty smell, and the blood-based sprays to keep these critters out of my garden.
You’ll often see these two home remedies recommended everywhere: hanging bars of Irish Spring soap from tree branches, and scattering human hair around the garden. Both are long-standing garden folklore, and plenty of gardeners swear by them online. In my experience, neither one has worked, and I, personally, would not count on either as your main line of defense.
There are also people who swear by coyote urine and ammonia-soaked rags. These might work in some yards, but again, they don’t work for me.
Things I Use in My Gardens
Auditory and Visual Deer Deterrents
Most deer are skittish creatures, so some deer can be deterred with fabric strips fluttering in the wind or wind chimes strategically scattered around your yard. My deer couldn’t care less about these things. I scream at them, walk up to them, and they just stare me down! Others have luck with sound frequency gadgets that you can buy.
One of the only things that I have found to work for me is a motion sensor sprinkler. It detects the deer’s movements and squirts them with a spray of water. They will get used to where this is and just avoid that spot so I have to move it around. I typically don’t start using it until mid-summer when they’ve devoured the gardens of those less diligent and start to venture my way.
I always forget it’s on and scare myself when I get squirted with water while taking my daily garden walk.
One of My Favorite Tricks
One of my favorite tricks didn’t come from a gardening guide at all. It came from driving past a neighbor’s yard full of small pinwheels. The constant, erratic movement in the wind turned out to be one of the more effective deterrents I’ve tried. My yard looks a little chaotic when they’re all up (I take them down for special occasions), but they’ve kept deer off my most delicate plants. As with the sprinklers, moving them around the garden periodically keeps them working.
Physical Barriers and Fencing: Even without Fencing the Whole Yard
Full perimeter fencing isn’t an option for every gardener. Village regulations, HOA rules, budget, or just wanting to preserve an open view can all rule it out. That’s the case in our yard. The only fence that I can have is a small one around my vegetable garden. And it works, it’s the one spot in our yard the deer never touch.
The good news is that fencing doesn’t have to mean enclosing your entire property to be useful. Smaller-scale and temporary fencing options can protect your most vulnerable plants without a permit or an HOA fight.
- Chicken wire or UV-protected plastic netting around raised beds or individual plants, low profile enough to avoid blocking sightlines.
- Temporary fencing (like plastic deer netting on stakes) around new growth plants will sometimes work. However, once they discover what’s behind the fencing, they will knock it over. Then it’s time to set up the sprinkler!
- Fishing line strung at deer height around the garden perimeter is nearly invisible but will disrupt the deer enough to keep them out. Skip this one if pets or people might walk or run into that area.
For gardeners who can put up a full perimeter fence, here’s a quick reference on the main types and how they compare:
| Fence Type | Height | Maintenance | Visibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tall Fences | 8+ ft | Low | Low |
| Electric Fences | Variable | High | Variable |
| Stockade Fences | 8+ ft | Moderate | High |
| Chicken Wire | Custom | Low | High |
| Plastic Netting | Custom | Low | High |
| Double Fencing | 8+ ft | Low | Moderate |
Tall fences are the most reliable since deer can clear anything under 8 feet. Electric fencing adds a shock deterrent but takes more maintenance and always needs visible warning signage. Stockade fences look great but require regular gap checks. Double fencing takes advantage of deer’s poor depth perception: two fences 3 to 5 feet apart can be enough to keep them out even at a shorter height.
Deer-Resistant Plants for Your Garden
Filling your garden with plants that deer find distasteful is one of the safest long-term strategies. There are a few that I have in my beds:
- Aromatic plants: Lavender, Sage, Rosemary
- Moisture-rich, but deer-resistant: Lamb’s ear, Russian sage
- For color: Snapdragons, Marigolds
The fact that I love a cottage garden look, which requires plants that the deer do love, means being strategic with my planting of the undesirable plants around or behind as a buffer.
Strategic Garden Layout to Deter Deer
Layout matters as much as plant choice. A few strategies you can try are:
- Border with aromatics: Ring garden beds with strong-smelling aromatic plants that deer tend to avoid.
- Layering by Height: Tall, deer-resistant plants towards the back of your garden, and low, sturdy plants in the front.
Building a deer-resistant garden isn’t only about what you plant. Where you plant it makes just as much difference.
Maintenance: Staying Ahead of Deer Damage
Once a deterrent system is in place, staying vigilant is what keeps it working. That means catching problems early and adjusting before deer settle into a routine of their own.
Walk the garden regularly, checking for eating damage, hoof prints, or telltale deer pebble droppings. If deer start favoring one area, move motion-activated sprinklers to cover it more directly. Step up your spraying in that area.
Like any routine, you need to be consistent. Let your guard down, and those little critters will be back with a vengeance.
FAQ’s
Does Irish Spring soap keep deer away?
It’s one of the most commonly recommended home remedies, but results are mixed and not well supported by research. It hasn’t been effective in my gardens, though some gardeners report success. It’s low-risk enough to test in a small area if your curious.
Does human hair keep deer out of a garden?
Like Irish Spring soap, this is a popular folk remedy without strong evidence behind it. It hasn’t worked for me, though it’s another low-cost option if you have easy access to hair clippings from a salon.
How tall does a deer fence need to be?
Most deer can clear fencing under 8 feet, so a full perimeter deer fence should be at least 8 feet tall to reliably keep them out. Double fencing spaced 3-5 feet apart can work at slightly lower heights by exploiting deer’s poor depth perception.
What is the best natural deer repellent?
Repellents built around egg solids, or blood meal (like Platskydd), tend to outperform folk remedies. Rotating between a few options and reapplying after rain keeps deer from adjusting to any one scent.
Can you keep deer out of a garden without a fence?
Yes. A layered approach of consistent repellent spraying, motion-sensored sprinklers, and deer-resistant planting can be just as effective as fencing. Especially for gardeners whose property rules, budget, or terrain rules out a full perimeter fence.
Keeping deer out of the garden is an ongoing project, not a one-time fix. It’s not for the faint of heart. Furthermore, if you’re fighting this same battle, I wish you luck. It’s worth it; nothing is more disheartening than watching a season of hard work disappear in a matter of days.
If you have tried something different that is working for you, please drop me a note in the comments below.
Peace and Love,
Would you like to save this?
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
A great way to save this idea is to add it to one of your Pinterest boards. You can find the pin button on the top left of the photo when you click on it. Also, don’t forget to follow me on Pinterest
Meet Me
My name is Lynn. I live in the suburbs of Chicago in a 1,300 sq. ft. home with my Handy husband, Keith.
I’m an open book about my life on my blog. You can find out more about me by visiting my “About Me” page.
These are great tips! We live on the edge of the woods too and while it’s beautiful to watch the deer grow and thrive it’s a bit sad to have them eat all of my tomatoes haha. We have lavender and rosemary in with the vegetables. I’ve tried using human hair and soap but they didn’t really work either. One of my tenants has a dog and that doesn’t even keep them away. I did put up a few flags all around the edge of the flower bed and that seemed to distract them for a bit. Last year we put a couple of tomato plants up on our front porch and that helped. So this year we were thinking about putting a few more things up there and see how it goes.
Hi Maria –
They are cunning and you have to keep them guessing. Human hair never worked for me either but Deer Off works really well. You spray it right on the plant. The trick is to remember to do it often. I do it every other weekend. I’m also incorporating Liquid Fence into my routine and that I’m doing once a month. I saw pinwheels in someones garden the other day and I think I might actually try that too. For me it’s a constant battle in the summer. Good luck and I hope that you get tomatoes this year. I find if I can keep them away in the beginning, once they are more mature the deer go for other plants.
Hi Lynn —
Sorry to hear of your losses in the “Bambi Battles!” Have you tried laying the bird netting on the ground surrounding the plants you want to protect? Deer will avoid it because they fear getting their feet entangled, or so I’m told.
A friend used green bird netting on top of his large hosta garden that encircled a big tree, plus about 3 feet around the perimeter. Although deer were plentiful in his neighborhood, he had really good luck with that. The netting wasn’t visible from the street, and whenever he wanted to mow the yard, it was easy to push or roll the netting out of the way, then replace it again.
Although I haven’t seen any deer in my neighborhood, I plan to surround my straw bale garden with bird netting, laid on the ground — just in case! Will let you know what transpires.
Cheers, g
Hi Gloria –
I have never heard of that before but it makes sense. I will try anything at this point. I’m off to Home Depot! 🙂
Try a 4′ fence, smaller mesh, laid horizontally just above the ground angling a foot or two upwards towards your yard. Make sure to warn people it’s there.
Hi Robert – That’s kind of what I’m think or doing because I can’t have an actual fence. I’ve already warned out neighbors who let their dogs run that I’m doing this. I should probably put up some kind of signs.